I got this for my husband who is both tall 6'2 and bulky (size 3x) because he is not very comfortable in SSCs. It is absolutely perfect for him and our toddler both. He no longer has back pain and with the higher back carry now she can see over his shoulder appropriately. She loves being carried by Dad instead of just ?Mom. The padding is nice and provides significant comfort for him, and he loves it so much I am losing out on carrying time.
I did try it for myself also, and it is comfortable but I still far prefer my SSCs and MehDais.